You are here
UN Green Award comes with responsibility: Global Champions remind Unilever CEO Paul Polman
Forty six prominent international human rights and environmental award winners from 30 countries have written to 2015 UN Champion of the Earth awardee and Unilever CEO Paul Polman reminding him that the award brings with it an “onerous responsibility.” The signatories include Dr. Vandana Shiva, 2011 UN Champion of the Earth awardee Dr. Olga Speranskaya, and Indian winners of Goldman Award like Bhopal activists Rashida Bee and Champa Devi Shukla, Chattisgarh-based Ramesh Agrawal, and Magsaysay winner Sandeep Pandey.
Pointing to the inconsistencies between Unilever's professed commitment to environmental sustainability and fair treatment of workers, the awardees have urged Polman “to personally intervene to ensure that an honourable settlement is offered to workers, and that the contaminated environment is cleaned up to international standards that are protective of the sensitive ecosystems that surround the factory site.”
“We are aware of your commitment to fairness and equal treatment of all people regardless of nationality or race. But Hindustan Unilever's proposal is a clear case of environmental double standards,” the letter states. “At a time when the United Nations is trying to build global confidence to tackle the Minamata Convention on reduction and elimination on sources of mercury emissions, the actions of your company come under added scrutiny,” it adds.
For more information, contact:
Nityanand Jayaraman – 9444082401
Chennai Solidarity Group, No. 92, 3rd Cross, Thiruvalluvar Nagar, Besant Nagar, Chennai 600090
Read the letter below and get more information here
24 September, 2015
Dear Mr. Polman,
We, the undersigned, are winners of international environmental and human rights awards. We extend our greetings and good wishes to you on your nomination for UNEP's Champion of the Earth Award.
We are aware of your vocal advocacy on the issues of climate change, sustainable development goals and fair treatment of communities, workers and the environment. The UNEP award too is a recognition of your words and actions.
We are sure, though, that you are aware of how the professed commitments of Unilever to justice and environmental sustainability are contrasted by your subsidiary's handling of the mercury legacy issue in Kodaikanal, India.
In 2001, environmental regulators in Tamil Nadu, India, shut down a polluting mercury thermometer factory in Kodaikanal operated by Hindustan Lever, a Unilever subsidiary, now renamed Hindustan Unilever Ltd (HUL). Between 1992 and 1999, the company admits to having sold 43.6 tonnes of mercury-laced broken thermometers containing more than half a tonne of mercury to a number of buyers including informal scrap merchants. It also admits to having discharged more than 2 tonnes of mercury into Kodaikanal's environment.
Workers in the factory say they were kept in the dark about mercury's ill-effects. They allege that the company thwarted all attempts to have independent and comprehensive medical examination done to verify their concerns about ill-health due to mercury exposure. A 2011 Government of India report that investigated worker claims concluded that workers had been exposed to mercury and many showed effects of mercury poisoning.
Till date, the management at Hindustan Unilever has failed to show serious intent to resolve the issues in Kodaikanal. Workers remain uncompensated, children and communities are suffering and the environment polluted. Minamata tragedy is being repeated in Kodaikanal.
We hear a lot about your passion for saving forests, and of your appreciation of the ecological services provided by forests. The Kodaikanal factory is located within and surrounded by valuable and endangered tropical sub-montane evergreen forests. These forests serve as watersheds for millions of people downstream and in Kodaikanal.
Your subsidiary is insisting on a clean-up that will leave more than a third of the mercury in the soil even after the remediation is completed. This mercury will leak out of the factory site into the air, the lakes and the waterbodies that lie around the factory site in Kodaikanal. The clean-up standard proposed for Kodaikanal, India, is 250 times weaker than the levels protective of sensitive ecosystems. This would not be allowed in the UK or any other Northern nation.
We are aware of your commitment to fairness and equal treatment of all people regardless of nationality or race. But Hindustan Unilever's proposal is a clear case of environmental double standards.
At a time when the United Nations is trying to build global confidence to tackle the Minamata Convention on reduction and elimination on sources of mercury emissions, the actions of your company come under added scrutiny.
We are very hopeful that you will bring your Indian subsidiary in line with the values you profess. We are sure that you are aware of the onerous responsibility that such an award brings with it. We urge you to personally intervene to ensure that an honourable settlement is offered to workers, and that the contaminated environment is cleaned up to international standards that are protective of the sensitive ecosystems that surround the factory site.
1. Yuyun Ismawati, BaliFokus, 2009 Goldman Environmental Prize, Indonesia. email@example.com
2. Olga Speranskaya, IPEN, 2011 UNEP Champion of the Earth; 2009 Goldman Environmental Prize. Russia. firstname.lastname@example.org
3. Vandana Shiva. Navdanya. 1993 UNEP Global 500 Roll of Honour. 1993 Right Livelihood Award. India. Vandana.email@example.com
4. Rashida Bee & Champa Devi Shukla. Bhopal Gas Affected Women Stationery Workers Association, 2004 Goldman Environmental Prize. India. firstname.lastname@example.org
5. Ramesh Agrawal, Jan Chetna Manch, 2014 Goldman Environmental Prize. India. email@example.com
6. Sven (Bobby) Peek, Groundwork, 1998 Goldman Environmental Prize, South Africa. firstname.lastname@example.org
7. Desmond D'Sa, SDCEA, 2014 Goldman Environmental Prize, South Africa. email@example.com
8. Hilton Kelley, Community In-power & Development Association, Texas. 2011 Goldman Environmental Prize. USA. firstname.lastname@example.org
9. Rizwana Hassan, Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers Association, 2009 Goldman Environmental Prize. Bangladesh. email@example.com
10. Sunita Viswanath, Women for Afghan Women & Sadhana – Coalition of Progressive Hindus, 2015 White House Champion of Change. USA. firstname.lastname@example.org
11. Gary Cohen, Health Care Without Harm, Skoll Award for Social Entrepreneur 2006. White House Champion of Change 2013. USA. email@example.com
12. Von Hernandez, Greenpeace International, 2003 Goldman Environmental Prize. Philippines. firstname.lastname@example.org
13. Phyllis Omido, Center for Justice, Governance and Environmental Action, 2015 Goldman Environmental Prize. Kenya. email@example.com
14. Thuli B. Makama, Environmental Law Center - ELC, 2010 Goldman Environmental Prize. Swaziland. firstname.lastname@example.org
15. Craig Williams, Kentucky Environmental Foundation, 2006 Goldman Environmental Prize, USA. email@example.com
16. Lois Marie Gibbs, Center for Health Environment and Justice, 1990 Goldman Environmental Prize. USA. firstname.lastname@example.org
17. Jean Wiener, Fondation pour la Protection de la Biodiversité Marine (FoProBiM), 2015 Goldman Environmental Prize. Haiti. email@example.com
18. Tarcísio Feitosa da Silva, Ministry of Public, Para State, 2006 Goldman Environmental Prize, Brazil. firstname.lastname@example.org
19. Juan Pablo Orrego S., Ecosistemas & Consejo de Defensa de la Patagonia, 1997 Goldman Environmental Prize. Chile. email@example.com
20. Bruno van Peteghem, Association Toxicologie Chimie, 2001 Goldman Environmental Prize, France. firstname.lastname@example.org
21. Nat Quansah, 2000 Goldman Environment Prize. Madagascar. email@example.com
22. Heffa Schücking, Urgewald. 1994 Goldman Environmental Prize. Germany. firstname.lastname@example.org
23. Maria Gunnoe, Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition, 2009 Goldman Environmental Prize, 2012 Wallenberg Medal. USA. email@example.com
24. Steve Wilson, Journalist, 2001 Goldman Environmental Prize. USA. firstname.lastname@example.org
25. Jonathan Deal, Global Citizens Alliance, 2014 Goldman Environmental Prize. South Africa. jonathan.deal@
26. Pablo Fajardo, 2008 Goldman Environmental Prize. 2007 CNN Hero Award. Ecuador. email@example.com
27. Harrison Ngau Laing, 1990 Goldman Environmental Prize. Malaysia. firstname.lastname@example.org
28. Feliciano Dos Santos, Musician/activist. 2008 Goldman Environmental Prize. Mozambique. email@example.com
29. Sviatoslav Zabelin, 1993 Goldman Environmental Prize. Russia. firstname.lastname@example.org
30. Ikal Ang'elei. Friends of Lake Turkana. 2012 Goldman Environmental Prize. Kenya. email@example.com
31. Christine Jean. 1992 Goldman Environmental Prize. France. firstname.lastname@example.org
32. Andrew Simmons. JEMS Progressive Community Organisation. 1994 Goldman Environmental Prize. St. Vincent and the Grenadines. email@example.com
33. Jadwiga Lopata, International Coalition to Protect the Polish Countryside. 2002 Goldman Environmental Prize. Poland. firstname.lastname@example.org
34. Kimberly Wasserman. Little Village Environmental Justice Organisation. 2013 Goldman Environmental Prize. USA. email@example.com
35. Ka Hsaw Wa. Earthrights International. 1999 Goldman Environmental Prize. 2009 Ramon Magsaysay Award. USA. firstname.lastname@example.org
36. Atherton Martin. 1998 Goldman Environmental Prize. Dominica.email@example.com
37. Cath Wallace. 1991 Goldman Environmental Prize. New Zealand.firstname.lastname@example.org
38. Rudi Putra, Forum Konservasi Leuser, 2014 Goldman Environmental Prize. Indonesia. email@example.com
39. Prigi Arisandi, ECOTON. 2011 Goldman Environmental Prize. Indonesia. firstname.lastname@example.org
40. Alexander Louis Peal. 2000 Goldman Environmental Prize. Liberia. email@example.com
41. Anna Giordano. Conservationist, WWF Italy. 1998 Goldman Environmental Prize. Italy. firstname.lastname@example.org
42. Ignace Schops. President EUROPARC Federation. 2008 Goldman Environmental Prize. Belgium. email@example.com
43. Tuy Sereivathana. 2010 Goldman Enviromental Prize. Cambodia.firstname.lastname@example.org
44. Maria E. Foronda Farro. 2003 Goldman Environmental Prize. Peru. email@example.com
45. Jadwiga Lopata. International Coalition to protect the Polish Countryside. 2002 Goldman Environmental Prize. Poland. firstname.lastname@example.org
46. Sandeep Pandey. ASHA. 2002 Ramon Magsaysay Award. India. email@example.com